(** We show that some operations on [FSet A] only exists when [A] has decidable equality. *) Require Import HoTT. Require Import FSets. Section membership. Context {A : Type} `{Univalence}. Definition dec_membership (H1 : forall (a : A) (X : FSet A), Decidable(a ∈ X)) : MerelyDecidablePaths A := fun a b => H1 a {|b|}. End membership. Section intersection. Context {A : Type} `{Univalence}. Variable (int : FSet A -> FSet A -> FSet A) (int_member : forall (a : A) (X Y : FSet A), a ∈ (int X Y) = BuildhProp(a ∈ X * a ∈ Y)). Theorem dec_intersection : MerelyDecidablePaths A. Proof. intros a b. destruct (merely_choice (int {|a|} {|b|})) as [p | p]. - refine (inr(fun X => _)). strip_truncations. refine (transport (fun z => a ∈ z) p _). rewrite (int_member a {|a|} {|b|}), X. split ; apply (tr idpath). - left. strip_truncations. destruct p as [c p]. rewrite int_member in p. destruct p as [p1 p2]. strip_truncations. apply (tr(p1^ @ p2)). Defined. End intersection. Section subset. Context {A : Type} `{Univalence}. Definition dec_subset (H1 : forall (X Y : FSet A), Decidable(X ⊆ Y)) : MerelyDecidablePaths A := fun a b => H1 {|a|} {|b|}. End subset. Section decidable_equality. Context {A : Type} `{Univalence}. Definition dec_decidable_equality (H1 : DecidablePaths(FSet A)) : MerelyDecidablePaths A. Proof. intros a b. destruct (H1 {|a|} {|b|}) as [p | n]. - pose (transport (fun z => a ∈ z) p) as t. apply (inl (t (tr idpath))). - refine (inr (fun p => _)). strip_truncations. apply (n (transport (fun z => {|z|} = {|b|}) p^ idpath)). Defined. End decidable_equality. Section length. Context {A : Type} `{Univalence}. Variable (length : FSet A -> nat) (length_singleton : forall (a : A), length {|a|} = 1) (length_one : forall (X : FSet A), length X = 1 -> {a : A & X = {|a|}}). Theorem dec_length (a b : A) : Decidable(merely(a = b)). Proof. destruct (dec (length ({|a|} ∪ {|b|}) = 1)). - destruct (length_one _ p) as [c Xc]. refine (inl _). assert (merely(a = c) * merely(b = c)). { split. * pose (transport (fun z => a ∈ z) Xc) as t. apply (t(tr(inl(tr idpath)))). * pose (transport (fun z => b ∈ z) Xc) as t. apply (t(tr(inr(tr idpath)))). } destruct X as [X1 X2] ; strip_truncations. apply (tr (X1 @ X2^)). - refine (inr(fun p => _)). strip_truncations. rewrite p, idem in n. apply (n (length_singleton b)). Defined. End length.